|SHADOWS ON THE WALL | REVIEWS | NEWS | FESTIVAL | AWARDS | Q&A | ABOUT | TALKBACK|
|Shadows off the beaten path|
Indies, foreign, docs and shorts...
|See also: SHADOWS FILM FESTIVAL | Last update 7.Apr.21|
A Common Crime Un Crimen Común
Review by Rich Cline |
BERLIN FILM FEST
Is it streaming?
Shot with an eerie calmness, this understated Argentine drama quietly shifts into gnawing, internalised horror. This psychological approach makes the film gripping to watch, especially as the narrative is underlaid with resonant themes relating to social responsibility and police corruption, astutely filtered through class consciousness. The approach might be too low-key for genre fans, but filmmaker Francisco Marquez laces scenes with both nerve-jangling emotions and provocative ideas.
Sociology professor Cecilia (Carricajo) has a relaxed life as a single mother, enjoying her spare time with her cheeky young son Juan (Pardo) and her maid Nebe (Martinez). Then one rainy night, she ignores Nebe's teen son Kevin (Otazo) as he bangs on the door, paralysed by fear. When the news breaks that he was murdered by police later that night, protests erupt in the streets, while Cecilia is tormented with her guilty secret. And when strange things begin happening around the house, she begins to believe that Kevin's ghost is haunting her.
The film is shot in a claustrophobic Academy ratio, with most scenes playing out in oppressive silence, as Cecilia sneaks glances at each of the other characters, frightened of her own shadow. Aside from her jangling nerves, Cecilia is thoughtful and observant, and there's an everyday sensibility to the way she interacts with each person around her. But scenes are shot and edited to add increasing unease, allowing the audience to experience each event through Cecila's anxious eyes. And in a clever touch, people keep noticing that she has something in her eye.
Performances are remarkably subtle, keeping the enormous emotions bottled inside. Carricajo is terrific at the centre as a methodical, intelligent woman whose suppressed feelings are causing her to unravel. Her face is a bundle of conflicting emotions, which we interpret differently from the other characters, especially Martinez's warm, understandably stunned Nebe. And because Cecilia refuses to share her pain, others treat her with almost banal normality, which skilfully tightens the screws.
Marquez maintains a hushed tone throughout each sequence, leaving the plot in the background while shifting focus to what remains unspoken between the characters. And the camera rarely leaves Cecilia's face, even when she's interacting with others. All of this makes watching the film rather demanding, especially as many scenes move in achingly slow silence. While a rollercoaster scene is a little on-the-nose, more random touches add churning undercurrents that are devastating. And bigger ideas give the terror an unexpected weight.
Review by Rich Cline | MUST SEE
dir Andrei Konchalovsky
scr Andrei Konchalovsky, Elena Kiseleva
prd Alisher Usmanov, Andrei Konchalovsky
with Julia Vysotskaya, Vladislav Komarov, Andrei Gusev, Yulia Burova, Sergei Erlish, Dimitriy Kostyaev, Goga Pipinashvili, Pyotr Olev, Vyacheslav Pigarev, Artyom Krisin, Yuri Grishin, Kseniya Komarova
release Rus 12.Nov.20,
UK 15.Jan.21, US 29.Jan.21
VENICE FILM FEST
Is it streaming?
Shot in pristine black and white like a 1960s film, this Russian drama is infused with an electric sense of earthy realism. Expertly directed by Andrei Konchalovsky, this long-suppressed true story becomes a staggeringly clear-eyed depiction of life in the Cold War-era Soviet Union. All of which makes it viscerally involving as the narrative explores a pattern of political injustices that's shamefully recognisable today around the world.
In the industrial town Novocherkassk in 1962, local council member Lyuda (Vysotskaya) is having an affair with her married boss Loginov (Komarov). She lives with her father (Erlish) and feisty teen daughter Svetka (Burova), and remains loyal to the Communist Party even as she's weary of food rationing and promises of a better future that never arrives. When the Soviet government raises prices, factory workers go on strike, then march in force to the council offices. The military responds with a bloodbath. Afterwards, Lyuda becomes desperate to find Svetka, who went missing in the chaos.
Each sequence bristles with details of life in this place and time, while the story is populated with characters who interact in sparky ways that add powerful resonance to both intimate moments and expansive themes. The action flickers between various fronts, exploring the layers of control from party bosses to powerless workers. The way officials casually identify and persecute anyone who looks shifty is chilling. And these officials are also being squeezed from above, constantly seeking a back door through which they can make their escape.
Vysotskaya delivers a storming performance as a woman full of attitudes and opinions, putting party over everything until it touches her personally. Her emotional moments are staggering. But her stubborn devotion to the Stalinist ideal is slowly eroded by this series of events, which spark her father to matter-of-factly recount nightmarish "unofficial" stories from his past. Indeed, Erlish is a standout in the ensemble, as are Komarov, Gusev (as a helpful KGB agent) and Kostyaev (as the panicky factory boss).
Both elaborately staged crowd sequences and small dramatic moments are riveting, superbly shot and played for maximum impact, maintaining intensity with an accompanying wry sense of irony. The officials' main concern is that news of this incident doesn't get out, classifying the events as a state secret, arresting anyone who was there, even repaving the town square to get rid of the blood, then staging a huge party. The massacre wasn't confirmed or investigated until after the Soviet Union's collapse in 1991.
See also: SHADOWS FILM FESTIVAL
© 2021 by Rich Cline, Shadows
on the Wall
|HOME | REVIEWS | NEWS | FESTIVAL | AWARDS
| Q&A | ABOUT | TALKBACK|