The Emperorís Club
2 out of 5 stars
R E V I E W   B Y   R I C H   C L I N E
the emperor's club Slick production values, a superior cast and an extremely heartwarming story make sure this film is always watchable, even if it never has the nerve to go for broke. The story is an extended flashback, as the legendary history teacher Mr Hundert (Kline) reunites with the boys he taught 25 years earlier at an exclusive prep school. Back in the '70s, Mr Hundert is a lively and serious teacher, challenging his students to think about the lessons of ancient civilisations. The story centres on four students: the intelligent but shy Martin (Dano, then 25 years later Culp), the popular renegade senator's son Sedgewick (Hirsch, then Gretsch), the brainy-but-fun Deepak (Mehta, then Khanna) and good-time-boy Louis (Eisenberg, then Dempsey). While students, these four get involved in various adventures, then compete for the coveted title of Mr Julius Caesar. Years later, mistakes they and Mr Hundert made finally have a chance to be rectified.

The title could easily have been Dead Emperors Society, although that might have implied a streak of anarchic humour running through the film. And there's none of that. Rather, we get an earnest examination of morality and humanity--good stuff, but without a badly needed blast of fresh air to make it believable. It's beautifully filmed in warm shades of amber and the story itself has several intriguing twists (no one is pure of heart here). But it's all so solemn that it hurts to watch! Hundert is a complicated man full of hopes and regrets, and Kline plays the role very well indeed, although he's strangely muted. Of the teens, Dano and Hirsch are standouts; Hirsh (Dangerous Lives of Altar Boys) gets the showier wise-guy role and the far more complex Dano (L.I.E.) shines in every scene he's in. On the other hand, the plot is far-fetched if you think about it, forcing the Caesar-Brutus parallel and engaging in far too much cornball inspiration to really mean anything. Basically, why doesn't Hundert learn from history when that's his job? Why is the Mr Julius Caesar title so coveted? Wouldn't the winner just be King of the History Nerds? And why do filmmakers insist on making these mushy, sanitised school dramas when real life is so much more raw and untidy?

cert PG adult themes 30.Oct.02

dir Michael Hoffman
scr Neil Tolkin
with Kevin Kline, Embeth Davidtz, Rob Morrow, Harris Yulin, Paul Dano, Emile Hirsch, Rishi Mehta, Jesse Eisenberg, Steven Culp, Joel Gretsch, Rahul Khanna, Patrick Dempsey
release UK tbc; US 22.Nov.02
FineLine
02/US 1h42

The boys. Mehta, Hirsch, Eisenberg and Dano play the top four students in Mr Hundert's class...

kline
R E A D E R   R E V I E W S
send your review to Shadows... the emperor's club Still waiting for your comments ... don't be shy.
© 2002 by Rich Cline, Shadows on the Wall

HOME | AWARDS | NEWS | FESTIVAL | Q&A | ABOUT | TALKBACK