Filmed in Dublin's historic Kilmainham Prison, there's an authenticity to this film that disarms most criticism. The basic problem is that the production and editing are theatrical and slightly amateurish, shying away from putting more difficult imagery on screen (violence? sex?). These under-explained actions and histories make it hard to get into the minds of the characters, although the performances are strong and provocative. Brady's Eileen is terrifically sympathetic. Her past is kept fairly mysterious, but her tenacity shows, and Brady avoids both shallow heroism and cheesy vilification. Meanwhile, Bradley's Aine is such a bundle of nerves that it takes us a long time to warm to her--a brave move for what's essentially the audience's point of identification with the entire film! But the effort is worth it, and by the end we come to understand Aine in a much more complex, interesting way. The interrelationships between the women and with governor and priest are also fascinating, as are the rumours and reports of life outside, which we never see besides a few golden-hued flashbacks. And even if the film stumbles in its somewhat heavy-handed approach as well as a refusal to fill in some gaping holes, it's still a great story that needs to be told.