Support Shadows: Buy a Poster

Yes, the story is truly silly, but it maintains a timeless quality that lets us suspend our cynical disbelief. This is helped hugely by the fact that the script is loaded with warped, deranged bits of humour that keep grown-ups laughing all the way from a vicious Keebler joke at the beginning, through a series of groaner running gags, to the Ringwraith-like Central Park Rangers at the end. Ferrell is hopelessly miscast, but that's part of the film's charm. He's too old and stiff and yet makes Buddy loveable anyway. Casting pros like Asner and Newhart in key roles is a stroke of genius, as is the hilarious cameo from Dinklage. Favreau directs the film like a holiday classic--bright and wacky, with witty touches and references that will make the film enjoyable over multiple viewings. He mishandles the climactic action scene though, only just barely capturing the script's witty blend of humour, sentiment and excitement. But this doesn't dampen the film's Christmas spirit at all; I promise you'll leave the cinema with a silly grin on your face.